Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares

John Marcarian   |   4 Nov 2024   |   5 min read

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas. 

Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home?”

If you’re an Australian expat in the USA, there are a few things to know about the tax implications of holding Australian shares. 

You may already be aware of how the franking credit system in Australia works and how tax credits are tied to dividends. 

However, the US doesn’t have an equivalent system. 

Here’s how taxes on your shares work when you’re a US tax resident.

What It Means To Be A US Tax Resident

Let’s assume you’ve moved to the USA and are now a US tax resident. 

When you lived in Australia, you paid tax on all your worldwide income. 

Now, as a US tax resident, you’ll only need to pay Australian taxes on assets with a direct link to Australia.

However, the USA also taxes worldwide income, so income from both Australian and US sources must be reported. US tax rates vary by income type—ordinary income, capital gains, and qualified dividends, each with its own rate.

Owning Australian Shares

If you own shares in Australian companies, here’s how taxes apply to dividend income from those shares.

  • Franked Dividends: In Australia, franking credits are added to dividends to reduce double taxation. For expats, these credits usually cover Australian taxes, so you won’t pay additional Australian taxes on franked dividends. However, no tax refund is provided for these credits, even though they offset your Australian tax obligation.
  • Unfranked Dividends: Unfranked dividends don’t come with franking credits, so they’re taxed differently. Under the Australia/USA tax agreement, Australia caps the tax on unfranked dividends for US residents at 15%. Be sure to notify the share company that you’re a non-resident so they can apply the correct withholding tax; otherwise, you may need to report it later your tax return.
  • Reporting in the USA: The USA considers dividends from Australian shares as taxable income. However, you may be able to claim the franking credit or tax withholding as a foreign tax credit, which reduces your US tax bill.

Inheriting Australian Shares

Australia doesn’t have an inheritance tax. So, when you inherit shares, they’re either valued based on their market price on the date of death or the original cost base paid for the asset. It depends on when the asset was acquired by the deceased. This amount becomes your “cost base,” which you’ll use later to calculate any capital gains tax if you sell the shares.

In the US, while beneficiaries aren’t directly taxed on inherited assets, an estate tax could apply to the estate if it’s large enough. The fair market value on the date of inheritance serves as your cost base for capital gains. 

Buying & Selling Australian Shares

Purchasing shares in Australia as a non-resident doesn’t trigger any immediate tax consequences. In usual cases non-residents don’t pay tax on the sale of Australian listed shares.

There is a narrow category of share sales that would be taxable in Australia, however. Generally, these relate to shares in companies that have Australian real estate.

The US imposes a capital gains tax, with different rates for long-term and short-term holdings. You may claim the Australian tax paid as a credit against any US tax due on the same capital gain to avoid double taxation.

Understanding Double Taxation

Australia and the USA have a tax agreement to prevent double taxation. 

This means that while you’ll need to report your income in both countries, you can usually apply tax credits for Australian taxes paid against your US taxes on the same income.

Using The Check The Box Election To Simplify Tax Treatment

For Australian expats with ownership stakes in Australian companies or entities, the Check the Box Election can offer significant tax flexibility and may simplify your US tax obligations.

The Check the Box election is a choice US taxpayers can make to treat an Australian business entity (such as a private company) as either a corporation or a pass-through entity for US tax purposes. 

If you choose to treat the company as a “disregarded entity” (for a single-member entity) or a partnership (for a multi-member entity), the income flows directly to you as the individual taxpayer. 

This may allow you to avoid some of the more complex reporting and potentially double-taxation issues that can arise with foreign corporate ownership.

However, if you opt to treat the Australian company as a corporation, it will be taxed separately, which can sometimes be advantageous but will introduce reporting requirements (such as filing Form 5471). 

Please consult with us further so we can better advise you of your position.

Holding Shares Through a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC)

If your shares are held through a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC), special US tax rules apply, which could increase your tax bill. 

The IRS defines a PFIC as a foreign corporation earning mostly passive income or holding mostly passive income assets.

US shareholders of a PFIC may face complex tax rules. 

To reduce tax, you might consider specific elections like the Qualified Electing Fund (QEF) or mark-to-market options, but these require filing IRS Form 8621.

Controlled Foreign Corporation (CFC) Rules

Under CFC rules, the US may tax you on undistributed income if you own a significant stake in a foreign corporation. If, along with other US taxpayers, you own more than 50% of an Australian company, the company may qualify as a CFC, requiring you to report certain types of income in the US.

Seek Professional Advice

International tax can be complex, and tax rules change often. It’s wise to speak with a CST tax advisor as we provide advice in both US and Australian tax advice.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in international dealings  If you're a US person or...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in...

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations

John Marcarian   |   30 Sep 2024   |   9 min read

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider. 

For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply to capital gains on the realization of assets, and what will your Australian and US tax obligations be? 

These are just a few questions this article will answer for you.

What Is Capital Gains Tax?

To begin, it is crucial to have a comprehensive understanding of capital gains tax concerning Australian expats. 

Capital Gains Tax or CGT is a tax on the profit made from selling an item classified as an asset. In Australia, as in the United States, CGT is complex and different from other taxes. Let us review both Australian and US CGT and then bring them together.

Australian CGT Tax

In Australia, CGT applies to any asset acquired after 20 September 1985. 

Selling an asset for more than it costs means you have a capital gain and must pay CGT. If an asset is sold for less than it cost, this results in a capital loss that can offset against current or future capital gains.

Generally, if an Australian tax resident makes a capital gain and the asset sold was held for at least 12 months, the 50% capital gain tax discount will apply. This results in half the capital gain being included in assessable income and being assessed at marginal rates of tax – which may vary between financial years. See the ATO website for the current individual tax rates. 

There are potential exemptions from the capital gains tax regime, including the main residence exemption.

A person’s main residence, which was moved into as soon as practicable after purchase and continues to be a person’s main residence for the entire ownership period, and on sale, if still a tax resident of Australia, will be exempt from CGT.

In relation to the main residence exemption, new laws passed in 2019, which came into effect 1 July 2020 now mean a total loss of this exemption if the property is sold while the taxpayer is a non-resident of Australia. There are some exceptions known as life events but careful planning is required to ensure the preservation of this exemption.

US CGT Tax

Under US law, the tax rate applied to capital gains depends on the asset’s holding period.

For assets held more than a year, you pay long-term capital gains tax, usually lower than the tax on ordinary income.

For assets held for less than a year, short-term capital gains tax rates apply, equal to your normal income tax rate.

Your income also determines the percentage of CGT you pay in the United States.

Your US CGT rate will depend on your taxable income. It is best to check the IRS website for the most current income thresholds for which CGT rate applies. 

There are also special circumstances under which your capital gains might be taxed at a higher rate. For example, net capital gains from selling collectibles (such as coins or art) are taxed at a maximum 28% rate.

Australia-US Tax Treaty And Its Impact On Capital Gains Tax

For Australian expats in the US, the Australia-US Tax Treaty is particularly important to understand. First signed into law in 1982, the treaty has been updated several times since then to address changes in areas such as superannuation and non-US investments.  

The Australia-US Tax Treaty determines where your tax obligations lie between the two countries. The overarching goal of the treaty is “avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income.” 

As we explain in this article, the Australia-US Tax Treaty, allows the tax paid in one jurisdiction to be claimed as a tax credit in the other jurisdiction, in the event that the income is assessable in both.  

For example, if the US sourced income is first taxed in the US and the income is then assessed in Australia, the tax first paid in the US will be taken up as a foreign tax credit against the tax assessed on the income. If the foreign tax credit covers the Australian tax, then any excess foreign tax credits are lost. If there is a shortfall after the foreign tax credit is applied to the assessed Australian tax, then extra tax will be required to be paid.

Tax Obligations When Selling A Former Main Residence In Australia

Let us look at an example to demonstrate how the Australia-US Tax Treaty affects Australian expats when selling their former main residence. 

An Australian couple moves to the US and lives there for eight years. They have decided to sell their former main home in Australia (purchased in 2015 for AUD1,000,000 and now worth AUD3,000,000).

Australian Tax Considerations

This couple would be classified as foreign residents and would not qualify for the CGT main residence exemption. As such, they will pay Australian CGT tax on the AUD2,000,000 (AUD3,000,000-AUD1,000,000) capital gain. 

However, if this Australian couple moves back to Australia and are considered residents for tax purposes and they reestablish the home as their main residence, depending on the length of their absence from Australia and whether they rented the property out or left it vacant, will determine whether a full or partial main residence exemption exists.

This example makes it clear that planning the timing of the sale of your former primary residence can and will have material tax implications. With that in mind, it is critical to get professional tax advice to optimize any potential or upcoming CGT liabilities.

It is important to note Australia also offers certain life event exemptions if they occurred during the time this family lived abroad, which could make them eligible for the CGT main residence exemption. 

The life events this includes are:

  • You, your spouse, or your child under 18 had a terminal medical condition
  • Your spouse or your child under 18 died
  • The CGT event happened because of a formal agreement following the breakdown of your marriage or relationship

USA Tax Considerations

Any income earned, including employment income and realized capital gains, is subject to US tax. Australians who have become US tax residents, including green card holders and those in the US for over 183 days in the last two years, are taxed on worldwide income. This would include the AUD2,000,000 capital gain.

However, the U.S. allows a foreign tax credit for U.S. residents on US taxes owed against any tax already paid to Australia or vice versa. 

The Australia-US Tax Treaty requires that the combined taxes paid in both countries cannot exceed the total tax that would otherwise have been payable in the country where the sale occurs.

Australia And USA Combined Tax Considerations

If the Australian couple decided to sell their former main residence in Australia while being a non-resident for tax purposes, they will need to declare this income on both the Australian and US income tax return. 

As the property is situated in Australia, the first taxing rights reside with Australia. Tax will be applied at non-resident marginal rates on their AUD2,000,000 capital gain.  

For the US CGT, the tax on their AUD2,000,000 capital gain would be calculated depending on their combined income and the CGT rate applicable. 

Thankfully, this couple would not have to pay both the full amount of tax in Australia and the US, as the tax treaty allows taxpayers in each jurisdiction to avoid double taxation. In this case as Australia has the first taxing rights, the US would give the couple a tax credit for the tax paid in Australia and the excess tax paid will be carried forward.

CGT On Selling Shares Originally Purchased In Australia

Let us assume an Australian citizen moves to the US for a period of five years. During this time, they decided to sell the shares purchased while they resided in Australia.

The first aspect to consider is what their choice was when then became a non-resident of Australia. If an Australian tax resident moves to the US and becomes a non-resident and they hold a share portfolio, the choices on cessation of residency with respect to the share portfolio is either to take a deemed disposal or ignore the deemed disposal and treat the shares as Taxable Australian Property. 

A deemed disposal involves comparing the purchase price of the shares to the market value of the shares on the date that residency ceased. Importantly, there is no cash received with respect to this type of CGT happening and so if there is a large accumulated capital gain, then there will be a tax bill that requires payment from other funds. 

If the latter option is chosen (ie. they choose to treat the shares as Taxable Australian Property), any future sale of these shares are connected with Australia and a capital gain or capital loss requires calculation and reporting in the Australian income tax return, even as a non-resident.

Fortunately, the treaty provides a paragraph where future sales of this portfolio can be subject to tax solely in the US. If a choice is made to have future sales subject to tax solely in the US, then the deemed disposal on cessation of residency is ignored.

CGT On Inheritance In Australia

If an Australian citizen has lived in the US for 15 years and inherits an investment property and shares, what are the tax implications in both Australia and the US?

Inheriting Property

The original property was purchased for AUD500,000 and has a current market value of AUD2,500,000. If the property was sold on when inherited, there will be a capital gain of AUD2,000,000 (AUD2,500,000-AUD500,000). As Australia has the first taxing rights, tax will be applied at non-resident rates.

If they had no other Australian sourced income for the year in which the property was sold, tax on the capital gain of AUD2,000,000 would be AUD875,350.

The USA CGT tax on their AUD2,000,000 capital gain would be calculated depending on their combined income and the CGT rate applicable.

The Australian citizen would not have to pay both the AUD875,350 Australian CGT and US CGT as the treaty allows taxpayers in each jurisdiction to avoid double taxation. In this case, the US would give the person a tax credit totaling AUD875,350.

Inheriting Shares

If they inherit shares, they can choose to have any future sales solely taxed in the US under the Australia-US Treaty.

Get Help Navigating CGT For Australian Expats

There are many intricacies and challenges to navigating tax laws between countries. The information in this article may not cover some variables relevant to your circumstances and as such it is recommended you seek tax advice for your specific situation.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home” If...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in international dealings  If you're a US person or...

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in...

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties

John Marcarian   |   9 Sep 2024   |   6 min read

The U.S. government’s crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight. Many U.S. taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully understand their obligation to disclose these accounts, and even fewer realize the severe penalties that come with failing to comply. For U.S. citizens, residents, and entities with foreign financial accounts, the stakes are high.

Understanding FBAR requirements and the line between non-willful and willful violations, including recklessness, can mean the difference between a reasonable penalty or a financial disaster. A key case illustrating this legal battlefield is Bedrosian v. United States, a cautionary tale for those who might be unaware—or choose to remain unaware—of their filing obligations.

FBAR Reporting Requirements And Penalties: An Overview

U.S. citizens, residents, and certain entities are required to file an FBAR if the aggregate value of their foreign accounts exceeds $10,000 at any point during the calendar year. This requirement applies even if the accounts don’t generate taxable income. The FBAR is filed annually with FinCEN, separate from tax returns.

Penalties for failing to comply are steep:

  • Non-Willful Violations: Penalties for non-willful violations are generally capped at $10,000 per violation unless the taxpayer can show reasonable cause.
  • Willful Violations: For willful violations, penalties can be far more significant, often up to 50% of the account balance or $100,000, whichever is greater. In some cases, criminal charges can also be brought.

The difference between willful and non-willful violations is central to determining penalties, and recent court cases and IRS guidance have clarified that recklessness can meet the standard for willful conduct.

Bedrosian Case: Recklessness Redefined

In Bedrosian v. United States, the issue of recklessness in the context of FBAR penalties took center stage. Arthur Bedrosian, a successful businessman from Pennsylvania, had held foreign accounts with UBS in Switzerland. Despite being aware of his FBAR obligations, he failed to report one of his accounts in 2007. The IRS imposed a $975,789 penalty, citing willful failure to file.

Initially, the district court sided with Bedrosian, ruling that his actions were non-willful, and reduced the penalty to $10,000. However, on appeal, the 3rd Circuit Court found that the district court had applied an incorrect standard of willfulness, specifically underestimating the role of recklessness in FBAR violations. The 3rd Circuit clarified that recklessness can indeed qualify as willfulness, and remanded the case for further review. Upon reconsideration, the district court determined that Bedrosian’s failure to report the account demonstrated at least reckless disregard, and the original penalty was reinstated.

Key Case On Recklessness: McBride And FBAR Penalties

A landmark case discussing recklessness in FBAR violations is United States v. McBride. In this case, the taxpayer, Michael McBride, failed to file an FBAR for his offshore accounts. The court found that McBride acted with reckless disregard of the filing requirements, even though he claimed ignorance. The court emphasized that recklessness could be inferred from a taxpayer’s knowledge of the law and his failure to comply with it, even if there wasn’t a clear intent to break the law.

The McBride decision underscored that a taxpayer doesn’t need to knowingly violate FBAR obligations to be penalized severely. Acting recklessly—such as choosing not to learn the rules or ignoring clear indications that filing is required—can be sufficient to trigger the harshest penalties.

IRS’s Approach To Determining Willfulness: The Role Of Evidence

The IRS takes a broad approach when assessing whether an FBAR violation was willful or reckless. In doing so, the agency looks at various forms of evidence to determine whether a taxpayer’s failure to file was due to deliberate intent, recklessness, or negligence. Key factors include:

  • Prior Filings And Disclosures: The IRS may review past tax returns and FBAR filings to assess whether the taxpayer has consistently disclosed foreign accounts. A pattern of non-disclosure could suggest willfulness.
  • Foreign Bank Communications: Correspondence between the taxpayer and their foreign bank can provide clues about willfulness. For instance, if the bank warned the taxpayer about FBAR requirements, and they still failed to comply, this could indicate recklessness.
  • Education and Background Of The Taxpayer: The IRS will also take into account the taxpayer’s background and sophistication. For instance, someone with a high level of financial literacy, such as a business owner or an individual working in finance, is more likely to be held to a higher standard of knowledge regarding their obligations. In Bedrosian, for example, his years of financial dealings and awareness of offshore accounts contributed to the court’s determination of recklessness.
  • Taxpayer Behavior: Deliberate concealment, such as moving funds to different jurisdictions or closing accounts after learning of an investigation, can be viewed as willful.

The Internal Revenue Manual also provides guidelines for IRS examiners to follow when assessing willfulness. The IRS is particularly focused on patterns of behavior that demonstrate a conscious choice to disregard the law.

What Does This Mean For Taxpayers?

Taxpayers who hold foreign accounts must be aware of the serious consequences of failing to comply with FBAR requirements. The distinction between willful and non-willful violations is often determined by the taxpayer’s behavior and the totality of the circumstances, not just their direct knowledge of the law. The IRS will scrutinize the individual’s past filings, communications, and behavior to determine whether their failure to file was reckless or deliberate.

As seen in McBride and Bedrosian, recklessness doesn’t require overt intent to evade the law. Simply failing to act on information, or ignoring a known legal duty, can lead to penalties amounting to 50% of the account balance. The IRS’s focus on recklessness means that taxpayers cannot afford to be passive about their foreign accounts. They must actively ensure compliance or risk facing substantial financial penalties.

Conclusion

With the growing focus on offshore tax evasion, the U.S. government has ramped up its enforcement of FBAR penalties. The Bedrosian and McBride cases highlight the importance of understanding the broad definition of willfulness, which includes reckless conduct. Taxpayers who fail to disclose foreign accounts may face severe penalties, even if they claim ignorance. Staying informed and seeking expert advice is critical for anyone with international financial interests.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home” If...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in international dealings  If you're a US person or...

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For...

 

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472


20th Aug 2024
John Marcarian

Declaring Foreign Business Interests Navigating the US tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in...

The Terrible Twosome: Form 5471 And 5472

John Marcarian   |   20 Aug 2024   |   4 min read

Declaring Foreign Business Interests

Navigating the U.S. tax code can feel like tiptoeing through a minefield, especially when you throw in international dealings. 

If you’re a U.S. person or corporation with foreign business interests, two forms in particular—Forms 5471 and 5472—might already haunt your dreams. 

Dubbed the “Terrible Twosome” by some beleaguered taxpayers, these forms come with stringent filing requirements and draconian penalties for non-compliance. 

Here’s why you should never forget to file these forms, what the consequences of forgetting are, and some recent developments that might surprise you.

What Are Forms 5471 And 5472?

Form 5471 is essentially an information return that must be filed by certain U.S. citizens and residents who are officers, directors, or shareholders in certain foreign corporations. 

The form requires detailed disclosure about the foreign corporation’s income, assets, and shareholders.

Form 5472 on the other hand, is used by U.S. corporations that are at least 25% foreign-owned, or by foreign corporations engaged in a U.S. trade or business. 

This form requires disclosure of reportable transactions between the reporting corporation and related foreign parties.

While both forms may seem like just another piece of paperwork, failure to file them—or filing them incorrectly—can lead to massive penalties.

The Fines:

Staggering and Unforgiving The IRS takes non-compliance with Forms 5471 and 5472 very seriously, with penalties that could make even the most seasoned tax veteran wince. 

For Form 5471 the penalty starts at $10,000 per year per foreign corporation. 

If the taxpayer fails to correct the omission within 90 days of being notified by the IRS, additional penalties of $10,000 accrue every 30 days, up to a maximum of $50,000. 

Form 5472 penalties are even harsher, starting at $25,000 for each accounting period the form is not filed. 

After the IRS sends a notice of failure, an additional $25,000 penalty kicks in for each subsequent 30-day period of non-compliance, with no cap on the penalties. 

These penalties apply whether the non-compliance was willful or due to an innocent mistake, although options for relief exist in cases of non-willful conduct. 

However, this relief is often difficult to obtain and requires demonstrating reasonable cause for the failure. 

No Statute Of Limitations? Yes, You Read That Right

One of the most terrifying aspects of failing to file these forms is that it can leave your entire tax return open to scrutiny indefinitely. 

Normally, the IRS has three years from the date you file your return to audit it. 

However, if you fail to file Forms 5471 or 5472, that statute of limitations does not apply. The IRS could theoretically go back and audit that return 10, 15, or 20 years later. 

Recent Developments: A Small Ray of Hope?

A recent Tax Court case, Farhy v. Commissioner, had thrown a wrench into the IRS’s penalty regime. 

In April 2023, the court ruled that the IRS did not have the statutory authority to assess penalties under Section 6038(b) for failing to file Form 5471. 

The IRS had been enforcing these penalties for years, but the court found that there was no legal basis for these assessments.

However this Tax Court Ruling was subsequently overturned by the United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit on  3 May 2024.

Conclusion: Don’t Tempt Fate

If you have foreign business interests and think you might need to file Form 5471 or 5472, the best advice is simple: file them. 

Even if the forms are a headache and the rules seem complex, the potential costs of non-compliance—financial and otherwise—are simply too high to ignore. 

And as the Farhy case shows, while there may be occasional victories against the IRS, they are the exception rather than the rule. 

So, stay vigilant, keep those forms in mind, and avoid becoming another cautionary tale in the annals of tax non-compliance. 

The “Terrible Twosome” might be formidable, but with careful attention and professional guidance, they don’t have to be your undoing.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home” If...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully...

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US...

U.S. Estate Tax Exposure For Non-Residents With U.S. Assets 

John Marcarian   |   29 Jul 2024   |   5 min read

For many people the United States is a major investment jurisdiction.

Whether that investment is made into stocks, bonds, managed funds, real estate or shares in US private companies – the size and scale of the US market is often irresistible for international investors.

One of the downsides of investing directly into the US can be that non-residents of the United States who own U.S. assets can be subject to U.S. estate tax.

This can significantly impact their estate planning strategies by imposing a significant cost on their estate.

This article discusses the exposure of non-residents to U.S. estate tax, the benefits of estate tax treaties, the relevance of international wealth in estate tax calculations, and the formalities required to transfer U.S. assets to beneficiaries. 

U.S. Estate Tax for Non-Residents

Non-residents of the U.S. are subject to estate tax on their U.S. situs assets, which include real estate, tangible personal property located in the U.S., and certain intangible assets such as stocks of U.S. corporations. 

The tax rates range from 18% to 40%.

Importantly the exemption amount is significantly lower for non-residents than for U.S. citizens and residents, currently only $60,000.

Estate Tax Treaties

The U.S. has estate tax treaties with several countries, including Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, South Africa, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom. 

These treaties can provide several benefits, including:

Unified Credit

Some treaties allow non-residents to use the unified credit available to U.S. citizens, which can significantly reduce the estate tax liability. 

Exclusions And Deductions:

Treaties may provide for exclusions of certain types of property or deductions for debts, taxes, and expenses.

Relief From Double Taxation:

Treaties can prevent double taxation by providing rules for the allocation of taxing rights between the U.S. and the treaty country.

Relevance Of International Wealth

For non-residents, the U.S. estate tax is generally limited to U.S. situs assets.  

However, the international wealth of foreigners can still be relevant in certain situations.

For example, under some treaties, the U.S. may consider the decedent’s worldwide assets to determine the allowable unified credit or to apply pro-rata deductions. 

Example Calculation (Singapore Resident: No Estate Tax Treaty With US)

The non-resident owns a $1,000,000 U.S. property and has no debts or other deductions: 

1. Gross Estate: $1,000,000 (U.S. property) 

2. Exemption Amount: $60,000 

3. Taxable Estate: $940,000 

Using the U.S. estate tax rates, the estate tax liability would be calculated based on the progressive rates. 

For simplicity, assume the effective tax rate is around 34% for this taxable estate size: 

Estate Tax Due: $940,000 x 34% = $319,600

This is major cost on a deceased estate and something that can be planned for ahead of time.

They key point here is to be aware of strategies to minimize or eliminate US estate tax.

Example Calculation (Australian Resident: Estate Tax Treaty With US)

The U.S.- Australia Estate Tax Treaty can provide relief and reduce the tax liability. 

Consider an Australian resident who owns a $1,000,000 U.S. property and has $5,000,000 in worldwide assets. 

The unified credit for U.S. citizens in 2024 is $13,000,000. 

1. Gross Estate: $1,000,000 (U.S. property) 

2. Worldwide Estate: $6,000,000 

The proration of the unified credit is calculated as follows: 

Prorated Unified Credit = U.S. Situs Assets/Worldwide Assets  X Unified Credit

Prorated Unified Credit = 1,000,000/6,000,000 x 13,000,000 = 2,166,66 

The effective exemption amount is $2,166,667. 

 3. Taxable Estate: 

Since the U.S. situs assets ($1,000,000) are less than the prorated unified credit ($2,166,667), the taxable estate is reduced to zero. 

 4. Estate Tax Due: 

 With a taxable estate of zero, the estate tax liability is also zero.

Formalities For Transferring U.S. Assets

For those beneficiaries of deceased estates that have to deal with the transfer of U.S. assets from a deceased resident to a beneficiary, the following steps are required:  

1. Obtain A Transfer Certificate: 

The IRS requires a Transfer Certificate (Form 5173) to release the U.S. assets. 

This certificate ensures that all applicable estate taxes have been paid or secured. 

2. File Form 706-NA: 

The executor must file Form 706-NA, U.S. Estate (and Generation-Skipping Transfer) Tax Return, to report the U.S. situs assets and calculate the estate tax due. 

3. Pay Estate Tax: 

Any estate tax due must be paid. 

In the above examples, in Singapore the estate tax due is $319,600. Whereas in the case of the Australian estate no tax is due. 

4. Submit Documentation: 

Provide the IRS with necessary documentation, including the death certificate, will or trust documents, and appraisals of the U.S. assets. 

 5. Transfer of Title: 

Once the Transfer Certificate is obtained, the executor can proceed with the transfer of title of the U.S. assets to the beneficiaries as per the deceased’s will or trust documents. 

Conclusion

Other strategies exist to manage this exposure, including the formation of trusts in certain US states to hold assets.

The key point here is to plan the way you hold your U.S. assets as early as you can.

Indeed, those people who are non-residents of the U.S. holding US assets from countries that do not have an Estate Tax Treaty with the U.S. have the most severe exposure.

Please contact us to discuss any concerns or questions you might have with respect to holding US assets.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home” If...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully...

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US...

Understanding Section 962 of the IRC: An Essential Tool for U.S. Tax Residents with Foreign Investments

John Marcarian   |   30 May 2024   |   5 min read

The United States tax code presents a labyrinth of rules and regulations, particularly for U.S. residents with investments in foreign corporations. These complexities are magnified when dealing with Controlled Foreign Corporations (CFCs) and the associated immediate taxation of foreign earnings under Subpart F or the Global Intangible Low-Taxed Income (GILTI) regime. This article delves into Section 962 of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), explaining its significance and utility for U.S. tax residents in managing their foreign investments more effectively.

The Challenge: Immediate Taxation of Foreign Earnings

For U.S. tax residents with investments in foreign corporations, including those held through pass-through entities such as partnerships and S corporations, immediate taxation of foreign earnings is a significant challenge. This taxation arises annually under the Subpart F or GILTI regimes, compelling taxpayers to include foreign income in their U.S. taxable income, often leading to double taxation without relief mechanisms available to corporate taxpayers.

Corporate vs. Individual Taxpayer Treatment

The tax burden disparity between corporate and individual taxpayers under the GILTI regime is stark. U.S. corporations benefit from a reduced federal income tax rate of 21 percent, a Section 250 deduction that allows them to deduct up to 50 percent of GILTI, and the ability to claim up to 80 percent of foreign taxes paid as a foreign tax credit. This combination of benefits significantly mitigates the impact of GILTI on corporate taxpayers.

Conversely, U.S. resident individuals are generally taxed at a federal income tax rate of up to 37 percent on GILTI, without access to the Section 250 deduction or foreign tax credits for GILTI. This discrepancy creates a substantial tax burden for individual taxpayers, necessitating a strategy to level the playing field. This is where Section 962 of the IRC comes into play.

How Section 962 Election Works

A Section 962 election allows U.S. individuals to elect to be taxed on their GILTI and Subpart F income at corporate tax rates. When an individual makes this election, they are effectively treated as if they own their CFC through a hypothetical domestic corporation. This election provides several advantages:

  1. Corporate Tax Rate: The taxpayer is subject to the 21 percent corporate tax rate instead of the higher individual rates.
  2. Section 250 Deduction: The taxpayer can avail the Section 250 deduction, reducing GILTI by 50 percent.
  3. Foreign Tax Credit: The taxpayer can claim an indirect foreign tax credit for taxes paid on the CFC’s net income in the foreign country, up to 80 percent of the foreign taxes paid.

Practical Example Of Section 962 Election

Consider a U.S. individual who wholly owns a CFC in Germany with net tested income of $1,000 for GILTI purposes, having paid $150 in foreign taxes. Without a Section 962 election, the individual faces a 37 percent tax rate on GILTI, resulting in $370 of U.S. tax, without any foreign tax credit or Section 250 deduction.

However, with a Section 962 election:

  • The income is taxed at the corporate rate of 21 percent.
  • The individual can deduct 50 percent of the GILTI under Section 250, reducing the taxable income to $500.
  • Adding back the $150 foreign tax paid (gross-up), the taxable income becomes $650.
  • Applying the 21 percent corporate tax rate results in $136.50 of U.S. tax.
  • After claiming 80 percent of the $150 foreign tax as a credit ($120), the U.S. tax liability is reduced to $16.50.

Future Distributions And Tax Implications

The tax advantages of a Section 962 election extend to future distributions. In the example above, when the taxpayer eventually receives a distribution of $1,000 from the CFC, it will be taxed at the qualified dividend rate of 20 percent plus the 3.8 percent Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT), resulting in $238 of U.S. tax. Without the election, distributions would typically be subject to ordinary income tax rates, leading to higher tax liabilities.

When To Make A Section 962 Election

Despite its benefits, a Section 962 election is not always advantageous. Some scenarios where the election might not be beneficial include:

  1. Same-Year Repatriation: If the CFC’s earnings are repatriated in the same year, the benefits of the election may be negated.
  2. State Tax Considerations: Not all states follow the federal tax treatment. States like California do not tax Subpart F or GILTI until a distribution is made, meaning the Section 250 deduction and foreign tax credits may not be available for state tax purposes.
  3. Future Tax Increases: Future distributions from previously taxed earnings under a Section 962 election might be taxed at higher rates, potentially offsetting the initial benefits.

Conclusion

Section 962 of the IRC offers a powerful tool for U.S. tax residents with investments in foreign corporations to manage their tax liabilities more effectively. By allowing individuals to be taxed at corporate rates and claim deductions and credits typically available only to corporations, this election can significantly reduce the tax burden associated with GILTI and Subpart F income. However, the decision to make a Section 962 election should be based on a careful analysis of individual circumstances and potential future implications. Consulting with a tax professional is essential to navigate the complexities and determine the best tax strategy.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes on Australian shares I still own back home” If...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For example, how does the Australia-US tax treaty apply...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US taxpayers with foreign accounts may not fully...

 

Australian Expats Living in the USA: Holding Australian Shares


4th Nov 2024
John Marcarian

Managing taxes can be challenging, particularly when living overseas  Many Australian expats in the USA wonder, “What happens with taxes...

 

Australian Expats Living In The USA: Understanding Your Capital Gains Tax Obligations


30th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

Whether you have already moved to the United States or are planning to, there are tax implications for Australian expats to consider  For...

 

FBAR Violations And Recklessness: What You Need To Know To Avoid Hefty Penalties


9th Sep 2024
John Marcarian

The US government's crackdown on offshore tax evasion has placed the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) in the spotlight Many US...

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations

John Marcarian   |   28 Sep 2023   |   3 min read

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia. From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and lodgement of employee forms, there is a range of compliance requirements that your company must fulfill.

There are a wide variety of payroll tax considerations, including tax withholding and taxes payable on the amount of wages. These taxes are levied to fund social security, Medicare, unemployment and disability benefits, and other State and Local requirements.

Withholding Taxes

  • Employers are responsibility for withholding taxes from wages and paying this to the Federal government.
  • Some States also require withholding taxes to be withheld in relation to the income taxes on employee wages.
  • Employers must typically make regular payroll tax deposits and file quarterly payroll tax returns with the IRS.
  • State and Local tax agencies often have their own reporting and payment requirements.
  • Withholding taxes go towards the individual employee’s income tax obligations.

Payroll Tax Requirements

Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) Taxes

  • Funds social security and Medicare.
  • Social security tax rate is 6.2% for the employee plus 6.2% for the employer.
  • Medicare tax rate is 1.45% for the employee plus 1.45% for the employer.
  • Additional Medicare is payable at 0.9% for the employee when their wages exceed $200,000 in a year.

Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) Taxes

  • Funds state workforce agencies and unemployment insurance.
  • FUTA is payable by the employer and is calculated at 6% on the first $7,000 paid to each employee.
  • Payment of state unemployment taxes can often be used as a tax credit to bring the FUTA tax rate down to as low as 0.6%.

State Payroll Taxes

  • State Payroll Taxes may apply depending on the location of your business.
  • The most common State tax is State Unemployment Tax (SUTA), which is payable by the employer.

Local Payroll Taxes

  • Additional payroll taxes may be payable based on the zip code, county or municipality where your business is located.

Employee Forms

  • At commencement of employment, employees fill out a Form W-4. This guides employers on how much income tax to withhold.
  • At the end of each year, employers must provide employees with Form W-2, which reports the employee’s annual wages and tax withholdings.
  • On commencing employment, employers are required to verify an employee’s eligibility to work in the US. This is typically done through the I-9 Form.

Other Payroll Considerations

  • Workers Compensation Insurance
  • State Disability Insurance
  • Paid Leave
  • Health Care Costs for Employees
  • Retirement Plan Contributions 
  • Reimbursements and Stipends

Penalties For Missed Or Late Payments

The IRS may charge a late fee for employment taxes that are not paid on time. This is called a “Failure to Deposit Penalty”.

Payroll tax penalties are:

  • 1-5 days late: 2% of the overdue payment
  • 6-15 days late: 5% of the overdue payment
  • Over 15 days late: 10% of the overdue payment
  • More than 10 days from first notice: 15% of overdue payment

Other Employee Benefits

Other Employee Benefits you may be required, or choose, to pay, can include:

Retirement Plans

One of the tax advantageous retirement savings plans is known as a 401(k). Under this plan you would pay a percentage of each paycheck into your employee’s retirement savings account instead of directly to them.

Health Insurance

Employers must offer affordable health insurance that provides minimum value of 95% to full time employees (working 30hrs or more a week) and their children (until they turn 26).

Stock and Stock Options

Stock and stock options can be offered as a form of equity compensation.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some types of taxes also apply locally, meaning that...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal requirements, there are many factors to consider The type of...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both Australia and the US taxing their residents on their...

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both...

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local

John Marcarian   |   20 Sep 2023   |   4 min read

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level. Some types of taxes also apply locally, meaning that even within the same State you can pay very different taxes to other parts of the State.

  • The US Corporate tax system operates on a Federal, State and Local system. This means taxes and other compliance costs may be charged from all three levels.
  • Filing requirements, lodgement deadlines, and available deductions or credits often differ between locations.
  • Due to the complexity of Local variances, compliance with the Local tax laws requires specialised Local knowledge for the area or areas in which your business operates.
  • To optimise your corporate tax strategy, it is recommended that you consult with experienced tax professionals who have a Local understanding of US taxes, as well as international taxes.
  • Tax returns are typically based on a calendar year.

Choosing Your State

Since every State has different laws, it can be important to select the right State for your business operations. You will be required to register in every State that you operate in, however if you have no particular business requirement for which State or States you operate in, then it can be advantageous to select a State that has more well known and simple tax laws.

For instance, Delaware has no state income tax, a fairly straight forward tax system, and well-known corporate laws across the US.

Types of Taxes

Income Taxes (Federal And State)

  • The Federal tax rate for companies is 21% 
  • 44 States levy corporate income taxes. These taxes vary from 0% to 11.5%, with some states assessing taxes on a flat rate and others using tax brackets in the same manner that individual income taxes are assessed.
  • 43 States levy state income taxes, 41 tax wage and salary income, New Hampshire exclusively taxes dividend and interest income and Washington only taxes capital gains income. Seven states don’t impose any individual income taxes. Some states use a flat income tax rate, while others have a graduated tax rate depending on the individual’s income.

Sales Taxes (State And Local)

  • Sales taxes are similar to GST or VAT in certain parts of the world. However, as sales taxes are only imposed on a State level, the rates vary between 0% and 7.25% depending on the State.
  • There are also various Local governments within 35 States that impose an additional sales or use tax, which ranges from 1% to 5%.

Property Taxes (State And Local)

  • Local authorities such as cities, counties, and school boards, typically impose property taxes on the value of the property, including the land and the structure on the land.
  • Each State imposes different parameters on property taxes.
  • Property taxes can also be payable on purchase and/or sale of property.
  • Most States have a “homestead” exemption which reduces or eliminates the cost of property tax on your primary residence, subject to a variety of qualifications or limits, which vary State to State, or even within States.

Payroll Taxes (Federal, State And Local)

  • Federal payroll tax is paid by both the employer and the employee.
  • Some States and Local authorities also require some form of payroll tax to be paid. The most common type is State Unemployment Insurance (SUTA tax), which is payable by the employer.

Franchise Of Privilege Tax (For Doing Business In A State)

  • Some States require certain business organisations to pay a franchise tax, otherwise known as a privilege tax, for doing business in the State.
  • This tax is typically calculated on the net worth of capital held by the entity.
  • Some States use an economic and physical presence test to determine whether a business is taxed, while others have no written interpretation of the basis of their test for determining who is required to pay the franchise tax.

Gross Receipts Tax (State)

  • Some States apply a gross receipts tax on a company’s gross sales, without consideration of deductions for expenses.
  • Gross receipts tax applies to businesses, regardless of whether sales relate to business-to-business transactions or business-to-consumer transactions.

Business Licenses (State, Local, With Some Federal Regulations)

  • Business licences or permits may be required on a Federal, State, or Local level.
  • Business licenses can take some time to be processed, and they should be completed prior to commencing operations. The complexity of the application depends on your industry, as well as the locality managing the license.
  • Licences and permits typically need to be renewed on a regular basis.

Due to the complexity of the wide variety of Local, State, and Federal taxes, it is important that you obtain qualified advice regarding your business. If your business expands into additional locations you will need to get updated advice regarding the new location in which you are operating.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and lodgement of employee forms, there is a range of...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal requirements, there are many factors to consider The type of...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both Australia and the US taxing their residents on their...

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both...

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business

John Marcarian   |   14 Sep 2023   |   4 min read

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system. From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal requirements, there are many factors to consider. The type of legal structure you choose will impact your compliance and tax considerations obligations.

Type Of Entities

C Corporation (C Corp)

  • Separate Legal Entity that works like an Australian private company does.
  • Offers some asset protection due to legal structure.
  • Taxed at the corporate level and when profits are distributed as dividends, these are taxed in the hands of shareholders.
  • Has Directors, shareholders (stockholders) and a separate tax identity to the shareholders.
  • Federal income tax rate is currently 21%. State income taxes may also apply.
  • In some instances dividends may have a reduced withholding rate of 5% when paid to foreign shareholders.
  • Allows for capital raising, new shareholders or selling the business completely by selling shareholdings to new investors.
  • High compliance requirements including meetings, quorums, minutes, and other management formalities.

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

  • This is a simplified form of a company. In operation it is similar to an Australian partnership where control is in the hands of the members and profits flow through to the owners rather than being taxed at the entity level.
  • Provides similar protection, and more flexibility than a C Corp.
  • LLCs are not managed by Directors. They are managed by the members or an appointed Manager.
  • It is possible for an LLC to have a sole member.
  • Members do not need to be US residents.
  • Tax returns need to be filed if there are two or more members, however the profits are distributed to the members who pay tax on their share of the profits.
  • Can elect to be taxed as a C Corporation instead of being taxed in the hands of the members.
  • Can elect how profits are distributed to members. For instance, profits may be split equally between members, based on capital contributions, or in other agreed ways.
  • If foreign tax is paid on the profits to an Australian member, they can claim the foreign tax paid as a tax credit on their own assessment of profit distribution received.

Branch (No New Entity)

  • No separate legal entity, meaning Australian entity is directly responsible for tax and compliance requirements.
  • Branch profits may be subject to US tax as well as Australian tax, depending how the branch is established in the US. In this instance the Australian company can typically claim the foreign tax paid as credits to reduce the impact of double taxation.
  • As there is no additional entity there may be less compliance issues to consider with transferring profits from the US to Australia. 
  • Whether you need to establish a US entity or not, will depend on the nature of the business you are operating.

Taxation Issues To Consider With Your Chosen Legal Structure

Both Australian and US tax laws need to be considered regardless of the legal structure used to establish the US business operations. International tax issues will also need to be considered where members, Directors or owners remain residents of Australia.

Australian Taxation

  • If the US entity is controlled in Australia it may be treated as an Australian tax resident.
  • The Australian parent company will need to consider how the fees paid between the US and the Australian entities are taxed in Australia.
  • US generally imposes a 30% withholding tax on payments to foreign entities.

US Taxation

  • The US may tax income earned from any business established in the US, regardless of whether the operating company is a US or Australian resident.
  • Australian resident members or Directors may be subject to US taxes before considering Australian taxes on income generated from the US branch or entity.

Fees Between Entities

  • US transfer pricing rules require transactions between related parties to be at arm’s length. This means that the value of fees may be adjusted where it is not arm’s length.
  • Proper documentation is essential for consulting or management services between entities, including basis for fees charged. This can assist in ensuring that fees paid between the US and Australian entities are treated as required for tax purposes.
  • Fees must be ordinary and necessary business expenses in order to be tax deductible to the paying entity.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and lodgement of employee forms, there is a range of...

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some types of taxes also apply locally, meaning that...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both Australia and the US taxing their residents on their...

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and...

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some...

 

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations


5th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations With both...

Australian Companies Expanding To The USA: Understanding Your Expat Employee Tax Obligations

John Marcarian   |   5 Sep 2023   |   5 min read

If you or any of your key employees will be moving to the US when expanding your business, they may have unique tax considerations.

With both Australia and the US taxing their residents on their worldwide income, and taxing non-residents on income that is sourced within the respective country, it is important to be aware of double taxation provisions that help ensure an individual isn’t taxed twice on the same income.

Tax Residency

It is important to determine which country an individual is a tax resident of, as this will impact how that individual is taxed in each country.

When an Australian resident moves to the US for work purposes they will typically become a US tax resident if they establish a home in the US and reside there on a “permanent” basis. Factors that will be considered in determining whether residency changes include whether family is brought overseas with them, if they buy or rent a home to live in, and if they disconnect with ties back in Australia. 

Conversely an individual who lives in the US on a short-term basis, staying in temporary accommodation, and leaving their family back home in Australia, is more likely to remain an Australian tax resident.

A US resident who moves to Australia will face a similar situation. However, the US is fairly unique in taxing citizens on their worldwide income, even if they change their country of residency for tax purposes.

Expatriate Taxation Rules

It is important that you familiarise yourself with both the Australian and US tax rules related to expatriates, so that your key employees who travel from one country to the other have the right information to manage expatriate taxation concerns.

Foreign Earned Income Exclusion

When certain conditions are met, individuals from the US may qualify for the foreign income exclusion. This applies for individuals who reside in a foreign country and earn foreign income. As US citizens are typically taxed on their worldwide income, regardless of their tax residency status, this allows eligible individuals to exclude certain income from their US federal income tax return.

Foreign Tax Credit

Both Australian and the US allow provision for foreign tax credits to be claimed in their resident tax return.

This ensures they are not taxed twice for the same income from both the source country and their country of residence.

Tax Equalisation Policies

Tax equalisation policies are policies that aim to neutralize the impact of an individual’s tax liability when they are working on a global assignment. The objective of these policies is to ensure that the tax burden on an individual is similar to what the individual would have faced if they had merely remained living in their home country.

Australian Help Debts

In the event that you move an Australian employee to the US on a permanent basis, they may become a US tax resident. Ordinarily this would mean that they only need to lodge an Australian tax return to declare any Australian sourced income.

However, if the individual has an outstanding HELP, TSL or VSL debt, they will need to declare their worldwide income. While a foreign resident is not liable for Australian taxes on foreign sourced income, they are still liable for HELP debt repayments based on the value of their worldwide income.

Individual Tax Obligations In The US

As the employer you should be prepared to provide guidance to any key employees that you relocate from Australia to the US. This helps ensure that they aren’t caught unaware of their obligations and tax requirements while residing in the US.

Familiarise your employees with US filing requirements, which are not only different, but can be significantly more complex than Australian requirements.

  • The US tax return is based on the calendar year and the filing deadline is mid-April.
  • In the US, Individual tax brackets vary from 10% to 37%. The US does have a tax withholding system, that is similar to Australia, to help individuals manage their tax obligations.
  • Unlike Australia, where each individual must always file their own return, individuals in the US can file as a single person or jointly as a married couple, or separately as a married couple.
  • The US requires individuals to lodge a Federal Tax Return. However, depending on the State in which the individual resides, they may need to file a State income tax return as well.
  • Non-residents who receive US income are also required to file a tax return. This means that any employee who is only in the US on a temporary basis will need to file a US return as a non-resident.
  • Local Income Taxes may also need to be considered.

Employee Benefits

The US has similar benefits and options for employees as Australia does, however there are some key differences that an individual employee should be aware of so that they can make appropriate plans and decisions for their individual care.

Retirement Plans

US employers are not obligated to contribute towards retirement in the way that Australian employers are required to pay the Superannuation Guarantee. Most employers voluntarily provide retirement benefits through a 401(k) plan (similar to Superannuation).

Health Insurance

While the US has a federal health medical system, Medicaid, to provide free or low-cost health coverage, this is typically limited to low income and disadvantaged individuals. Without a universal healthcare system it is important to consider health insurance, which is commonly provided as an employee benefit.

NEED ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR SITUATION?

Contact us today
Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Do you need tax services in our other regions?
By providing us your information you agree to our privacy policy

More articles like this

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and lodgement of employee forms, there is a range of...

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some types of taxes also apply locally, meaning that...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal requirements, there are many factors to consider The type of...

 

Expanding To The USA: Your Payroll Tax Obligations


28th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has similar payroll tax requirements to Australia From withholding taxes on wages, to payment of payroll taxes assessed on wages paid, and...

 

Expanding To The USA: Understanding Corporate Taxation – Federal, State & Local


20th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

The US has a complex tax system, with multiple taxes, including income taxes, often being imposed on a State level as well as a Federal level Some...

 

Expanding To The USA: Choosing A Legal Structure For Your Business


14th Sep 2023
John Marcarian

Expanding to the US means you are entering a complex tax system From international tax concerns, to different Local, State, and Federal...