Why This Matters?
Many Australians arrive in the US with sensible portfolios at home such as ASX listed exchange traded funds, listed investment companies, unit trusts or managed funds, and sometimes investments held through family trusts or private companies. In the US those vehicles can fall under the Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) regime. That regime can impose punitive tax, interest charges, and heavy reporting. In addition, attribution rules can make you a PFIC shareholder even when you do not hold the shares directly. Understanding the touchpoints early allows you to restructure intelligently and avoid unnecessary cost and compliance friction.
What Is A PFIC?
A foreign corporation is a PFIC if it meets either of two tests in the Internal Revenue Code. The income test looks for at least seventy-five per cent of gross income being passive. The asset test looks for at least fifty per cent of assets that produce or are held to produce passive income.
In practice many non-US pooled funds are PFICs for US purposes. These include mutual funds, exchange traded funds, listed investment companies, and some investment companies.
Classification of Australian unit trusts depends on US entity classification rules and the facts. Many widely held, manager controlled vehicles are not treated as trusts for US tax and end up analysed as corporations, but this is fact specific.
Default Taxation And The Main Elections
If no election is made, PFICs are taxed under the excess distribution regime. Excess distributions and gains are allocated back over your holding period, taxed at the highest historic rates for each year, and layered with an interest charge that is not deductible. Two elections can improve outcomes.
- Qualified Electing Fund Election – You include your share of the PFIC ordinary earnings and net capital gain each year. The practical hurdle is that you need a PFIC annual information statement from the fund. Australian funds rarely provide it.
- Mark To Market Election – If the PFIC stock is marketable you mark to fair value each year. Increases are ordinary income and decreases are ordinary loss subject to limits. Marketable stock requires regular trading on a qualified exchange or market with published quotations. The ASX typically satisfies the regulatory criteria.
New US Residents And The Helpful Basis Rule
When an individual first becomes a US person and makes a timely Mark to Market election the regulations allow a basis step up. For Mark to Market purposes your adjusted basis is treated as the greater of cost or fair market value on the first day of US residency. That ring fences pre immigration appreciation from the Mark to Market computation. Other basis rules may still apply for non-Mark to Market purposes, so records matter.
Once A PFIC Always A PFIC And Purging
PFIC taint follows the stock. If the company was ever a PFIC during your holding period the stock remains PFIC stock until you make an appropriate election or purge. The law allows a purge by recognizing gain as of the last PFIC year. Planning before arrival is powerful. Disposing of PFICs before US residency or arranging elections in time can avoid years of complexity.
Reporting And Form 8621 With Small Holder Relief
A US person who is a direct or indirect shareholder in a PFIC generally files Form 8621 each year if they receive distributions, recognize gain, report a QEF or Mark to Market inclusion, make certain elections, or otherwise hold PFIC stock that triggers reporting under the statute. The instructions also explain who counts as an indirect shareholder.
There is limited relief. You may omit Part I of Form 8621 for a section 1291 fund if the aggregate value of all PFICs is not more than twenty-five thousand US dollars at year end or fifty thousand US dollars for joint filers and you had no excess distributions or gains. For indirect PFIC stock a five thousand US dollar per fund threshold applies. This is a Part I exception only. Other parts still apply if you made QEF or Mark to Market elections or had income. In most expat cases with meaningful balances or any distributions or sales Form 8621 is still unavoidable.
Attribution Rules And Why You Can Be A Shareholder Without Holding The Shares
Attribution rules sit in section 1298. Key points follow.
- Partnerships Trusts and Estates – PFIC stock owned by these entities is considered owned proportionately by partners and beneficiaries.
- Corporations – Normally attribution up from a corporation requires owning at least fifty per cent of that corporation by value. However, if you are a shareholder of a PFIC the fifty per cent limitation is waived for purposes of looking through that PFIC to its lower tier holdings. As a result, a PFIC that holds other PFICs can push those up to you even if you own only a small percentage of the top company.
- Options – Options to acquire stock are treated as ownership. Successive attribution applies so treated ownership can be pushed further up the chain.
What This Means For Australians?
Family Trusts That Are Not Grantor Trusts
A US beneficiary may be an indirect PFIC shareholder when distributions are attributable to PFIC income or gains. The Form 8621 rules indicate that a US beneficiary of a foreign non grantor trust generally does not complete Part I unless they have made a QEF or Mark to Market election or had an excess distribution or gain. When those occur, reporting applies.
Private Companies
If you own at least fifty per cent of an Australian private company that itself holds PFIC stock, attribution can push PFIC ownership up to you. If the company is itself a PFIC, look through can apply to its lower tier holdings without the fifty per cent threshold.
CFC Overlap Which Can Be Useful
If you control an Australian company and it is a controlled foreign corporation for US purposes, the CFC overlap rule prevents the same entity from being both a CFC and a PFIC with respect to you during the period you are a US shareholder. It is treated as a CFC only. This is often helpful for active businesses that might otherwise drift into PFIC status due to large cash or portfolio assets. It does not rescue widely held funds.
Treaty Relief Is Limited For PFIC
The US Australia income tax treaty contains a saving clause that allows the US to tax its citizens and residents as if the treaty did not exist subject to limited exceptions. As a practical matter the treaty does not neutralize PFIC outcomes for US residents.
Common Australian Holdings And Practical Choices
ASX listed exchange traded funds listed investment companies and managed funds usually require PFIC analysis. If you intend to keep them, consider Mark to Market if the marketability criteria are met. For new US residents, a timely Mark to Market election can use the first day basis rule. Otherwise, the default excess distribution regime is often costly.
- Unit Trusts Require A US Classification Analysis First – Many manager-controlled widely held unit trusts are analyzed as corporations but not always. PFIC status hinges on corporate status.
- Superannuation Requires Separate Analysis – US treatment is complex and can involve trust or deferred compensation concepts. Even where the Form 8621 instructions provide limited references for certain foreign pensions, the saving clause and lack of robust mutual pension recognition mean that PFIC exposure inside super is not automatically fixed. Specialized advice is essential.
- Direct Shares On The ASX Are Not PFICs – For many expats shifting from funds to directly held portfolios or to US domiciled exchange traded funds that provide global exposure is the cleanest approach.
Pre-Immigration And Early Residency Planning
- Prepare an inventory and classification of all non-US vehicles before moving. Confirm US entity status and PFIC status.
- Decide whether to exit PFICs before the move or to plan for a QEF or Mark to Market election where possible. For listed vehicles Mark to Market is often the pragmatic choice. For Australian funds QEF is rarely available.
- Use the Mark to Market first year rule where available to ring fence pre arrival gains.
- Map attribution through family trusts partnerships and private companies. Document the chain so you know who files Form 8621 and when.
- Do not rely on treaty relief to soften PFIC outcomes.
In Summary
For Australian expats building a life in the US the PFIC regime is more of a compliance hazard than an investment edge. Where possible migrate to US domiciled exchange traded funds even for global exposure or build separately managed or directly held share portfolios. If you truly need to keep ASX funds, a timely Mark to Market election usually provides a better long term result than the default excess distribution method. The most costly mistakes are assuming unit trusts cannot be PFICs missing indirect ownership through family structures and overlooking the first year Mark to Market basis relief.
This is general information only and not tax advice. For client matters confirm facts entity classification and filing positions against the current year rules and instructions.